Finding Mr. Christmas returned for Season 2 with a new group of 10 contestants competing for a career-boosting prize: a starring role in a Hallmark holiday movie. Hosted by Jonathan Bennett, the series puts the men through festive challenges and on-camera tests designed to evaluate acting potential, charm, and leading-man presence.
What the Competition Is About
Season 2 follows a structured elimination format where contestants tackle Christmas-themed assignments and performance-based challenges. The goal is to prove they can carry the tone Hallmark audiences expect: warm, personable, believable, and camera-ready.
When and Where to Watch Season 2
Season 2 premiered on October 27, 2025, airing on Hallmark Channel, with streaming availability through Hallmark’s platform, depending on region and subscription access. Hallmark also promoted a reunion special scheduled for December 20.
Finding Mr Christmas Season 2 Cast
Angel, 38 (Charlotte, North Carolina)
Angel is a model, actor, and bartender. He shared that he became a U.S. citizen in 2018 and approached the season with a studied, strategic mindset.
Craig, 33 (Lake Ronkonkoma, New York)
Craig is a personal trainer and actor who leaned into the show’s holiday spirit, sharing personal Christmas memories and describing himself as someone who goes all-in on festive energy.
Davey, 34 (Lake Tahoe, Nevada)
Davey is a commercial model and actor. He has worked with major brands and noted experience in high-profile production work, including being credited as a body double for Chris Hemsworth.
Drake, 27 (Denver, Colorado)
Drake is a model and social media manager who framed his approach around confidence, heart, and delivering a polished “leading man” presence on screen.
Gabriel, 32 (Laramie, Wyoming)
Gabriel is a model who shared that he recently became a father. He also noted entering the season with support from a longtime friend in the cast.
Jake, 36 (Lake View, New York)
Jake is a former NFL player and personal trainer. He said he didn’t have acting experience, but felt comfortable performing under pressure and in front of crowds.
Logan, 30 (Cincinnati, Ohio)
Logan is a server and photographer who described himself as more “quiet hobbyist” than showman, referencing interests like fantasy fandoms and building Lego sets with his fiancée.
Marcus, 32 (Hamilton, Ohio)
Marcus is a model and actor who said acting lessons—given as a gift—helped change his direction and pushed him to pursue acting seriously.
Robbie, 35 (New York, New York)
Robbie is an acting teacher who emphasized craft alongside charisma. He also shared personal life updates and highlighted humor and sincerity as strengths for the Hallmark style.
Rustin, 37 (San Diego, California)
Rustin is a musician who shared a holiday-themed story about meeting his wife. He positioned himself as someone who can balance warmth with a slightly edgier, rocker identity.
Judges and Notable Guest Appearances
Alongside Jonathan Bennett and Melissa Peterman, the season featured appearances from familiar Hallmark faces as guest judges and mentors, adding industry feedback and extra pressure to the weekly challenges.
By the finale, the competition narrowed to three finalists: Angel Garet, Craig Geoghan, and Rustin Sailors. Craig Geoghan ultimately won Season 2, earning the starring opportunity tied to the show’s main prize.
